Rubric Assessment:Grading a Design Rubric

An assessment of whether you can tell a working evaluation rubric from a broken one. You are given a finished presentation deck, the brief that produced it, and a rubric somebody wrote to grade that deck, together with the ten rules they were told to follow. You review the rubric and say what is wrong with it, up to five findings, each ruled on by two other people who read the same packet. The ten rules are published up front, and so are the defects we already found; restating either scores nothing. What is measured is whether the rubric would actually work. No design software needed, about 45 minutes.